Episode 1, Did Mary Actually Die Before the Assumption?

Watch the Episode 1

Listen to the Episode 1

Did Mary actually die before being assumed into heaven? In this brief reflection, we explore what the Catholic Church definitively teaches about the Assumption of Mary, the ancient tradition of the Dormition, and why the Church has never formally declared whether Mary experienced death before being taken body and soul into heavenly glory.

Read the Episode 1 Transcript

Did Mary Actually Die Before the Assumption?

Our question is: If Mother Mary was assumed into heaven and her soul never left her body, did she actually die?

That’s a fantastic question because the Church has never definitively declared whether Mary suffered death or not.

What the Church has definitively declared is the dogma of the Assumption of Mary—body and soul into heaven. In his Apostolic Constitution defining the Assumption, Munificentissimus Deus, Pope Pius XII wrote:

“The Immaculate Mother of God, the ever Virgin Mary, having completed the course of her earthly life, was assumed body and soul into heavenly glory.”

While the Assumption has been definitively declared, the Church has not unambiguously declared whether Mary actually experienced death.

Many of the Fathers of the Church had no difficulty saying that Mary died. After all, Jesus Himself suffered death. One could therefore say that Mary died in the sense that there was a moment when she breathed her last earthly breath, just as Jesus did.

That understanding would be fitting because Mary, as the perfect disciple, conformed her life to the pattern of Christ her Son—who suffered, died, and rose again.

The reason some hesitate to say that Mary died is because, in theology, death is defined as the separation of the soul from the body. Since Mary was assumed body and soul into heaven, some question whether that separation ever occurred.

To avoid confusion, I prefer the ancient tradition of referring to the end of Mary’s earthly life as the Dormition of Mary. The word Dormition means “falling asleep.” It describes Mary’s passing from this life as peacefully completing her earthly journey before being assumed body and soul into heavenly glory.

And where Mother Mary goes, her children hope to follow.

God bless you.